Sunday, September 7, 2014

SAMPLE Observation Evidence

This observation evidence text is for the purpose of learning how to use the observation tool in EDS/CIITS.


Lesson Summary:
Students began working on the bell--‐ringer problem quietly and waited until the teacher prompted them to ask questions.  Upon observation, some students merely copied the problem and turned their paper over and waited quietly.  (The math problem was a review from the previous day’s lesson.) Students asked questions of the teacher and she spent about 20 minutes answering questions until students appeared to understand (questions stopped).  Papers were collected by Ms. Bloom. 

Homework was then brought out by students and the teacher asked if anyone had any questions over any of the homework problems.  Hands were raised immediately and a multitude of questions ensued.  Ms. Bloom stated, “Most of you should know how to do these problems since they are very similar to the practice problems we worked together in class yesterday.  If you had given some effort and taken notes like I asked, you could have referred to them on this assignment.”  Some students commented that it was easy when they worked them together in class, and they thought they understood, but then after they got home they just forgot how to begin.  A few stated, “This is too hard.  We need something easier.  I don’t get it.”  After 20 minutes of working through homework problems, Ms. Bloom announced that she would go ahead and collect their work and would determine how to proceed with the material from that lesson tomorrow or the next day.

Ms. Bloom acknowledged the amount of time left in class and stated that it was very important to pay close attention to the notes she was about to give since this was an important topic on the state test at the end of the year.  She said that they would begin the lesson today and would finish up tomorrow, and would not have homework for the evening.  She stated, “I know that if you take really good notes, you all will do well.  This is difficult material, but you can do it if you work hard.  Some of you might have to work harder than others, but that’s okay.”

Examples were worked out by the teacher on the document camera and copied by most students.  Some students asked questions of the teacher related to the material being taught.  A few students sat quietly and doodled, but did not cause a disruption.

The bell rang in the middle of a sample problem.  Some students closed their books and stopped working when the bell sounded; a few others waited until the teacher dismissed them.


  
9:15 Bell rang; all Ss working on problem written on the board. 
3 Ss appear to have just copied problem and waiting quietly
T: “OK, the problem on the board is a review from yesterday’s lesson.  What questions do you still have about how to solve this type of problem?”
9:20 – S: “I still don’t know which number to use on the bottom.”
T: “Who can explain for Devin how to know which number is to be used in the bottom part of the equation?”
1 hand raised and T had S explain
T: “What other questions are there?”
Multiple hands raised
T: “Devin wasn’t here yesterday so I can understand his confusion, but the rest of you couldn’t have been paying attention if there are still this many questions.”
9:38 – T stopped answering questions and collected students’ papers
T: Get out your homework from last night.  What questions do you have about this assignment?”
Hands up across the room with students calling out questions they had.
T:”Most of you should know how to do these problems since they are similar to the ones we did together in class yesterday.  If you had given some effort and taken notes like I asked, you could have referred to them on this assignment.”
S: “They were easy when we did them together”
S: “Yeah, but then I forgot how to start on my own.”
S: “I don’t get it at all. These are too hard.”
S: “We need something easier.”
9:45 T began answering questions about homework
10:03 T: “OK, just pass your papers to the front and I’ll think about how to deal with this between tomorrow or the next day. 
10:10 T: “OK, we only have 20 minutes left so I need you to pay close attention.  We need to talk about some kinds of problems that will be on the state test.
S: “Not again.”
T: We’re going to start today and you won’t have any homework tonight.  But you need to pay close attention and take good notes.”
T: “This is difficult material, but if you take really good notes you all will do well if you work hard.  Some might have to work harder than others, but that’s OK.”
T showed examples using document camera and Ss copied. 3 Ss asked questions but T said to wait and they would understand.
4 Ss rested their heads on their desks

10:30 Bell rang in middle of sample problem. Most Ss got up and began walking out of class but a few waited until T formally dismissed them.